Island Jay's Product Reviews

Not sure about us? Take a moment to check out our customer's thoughts. We have almost 30,000 reviews and over 90% of them are 5 star.

Based on 28952 reviews
USA Flag & Palms T-Shirt
C Dove (Springfield, TN, US)
High Quality Patriotic Shirts!

These have such a fun patriotic, island vibe. Perfect for my beach loving, veteran husband. They are made of good material, too!

Retired But Not Expired Parrot T-Shirt
Daryl Barton (Brookings, OR, US)

Sweet T and fast friendly service

Mystery Bag Men's T-Shirt
Dianne East (Westmoreland, TN, US)
Mystery Tshirt

I ordered one from men's mystery bag and one from women's mystery bag.... you see something wrong???? Mines got a pirate and his going on a girls trip!!! Highly disappointed!!!

Super cute !

Super cute tee …colors vibrant and looks just as bright and colorful as on the computer screen… fit is perfect and try to size… nice quality material tee… company is in touch with you regarding your order with a little bit of island humor as well. I have bought a few of these tees and love them all … adorable colorful and fun😎

The Pontoon Boat Is My Happy Place 6" Beach Sticker
John Ripley (South Portland, ME, US)
I ❤️ Island Jay

Great products and fun customer service for this Florida ex-pat living in Maine! 🤙🏼🏴‍☠️🐊🌺

Retired But Not Expired Parrot T-Shirt
D. (Deerfield Beach, FL, US)
Retired but not Expired parrot tee

Just received this tee for my hubby & he loves it. Great quality & well made with double stitched on sleeves, neck & hem. Thank you Al for making such a fun tee!!

Winter Sucks Island Soft Style Pullover Hoodie
Betty Starbuck (Kansas City, MO, US)
Great hoodie!!

Love the feel and color! Getting lots of compliments on it!! Kansas winters really do suck and this makes me feel a little better!!

Winter Sucks Island Sweatshirt
Beth Davie (Springfield, MO, US)
Love my winter sucks tshirt!

Love my "winter sucks sweatshirt"! I have gotten so many comments on it! The color, the fit , the quality! All a ten!

Winter Sucks Island T-Shirt
Jay Lutz (Key West, FL, US)
Winter sucks ... So go to Florida

Ordered shirts for myself and my wife . Great fit and accurate sizing

Get On The Peace Train T-Shirt
Edward Contreras (DeMotte, IN, US)
Christmas with Island Jay Tee’s

So with designing new tee shirts with Island Jay we had to get one for everyone in the Family this year at Christmas! The kids love them and the quality of the shirts are always top notch with the fabric and artwork. Definitely a Family favorite! We highly recommended all the products at Island Jay!

Cape Shore Flamingo Ball Jar Shot Glass
Michele Cochran (Detroit, MI, US)
Shot glasses


I'm Not Waiting Til 5 Parrot T-Shirt
Alice Edwards (Houston, TX, US)
In love

I totally love Island Jay shirts! I have favorite is the one with the two beach chairs on the back with two margaritas!

Get On The Peace Train Soft Style Sweatshirt
Edward Contreras (DeMotte, IN, US)
Get on the Peace Train

We love our Tiki Man Radio Get on the Peace Train with Ed the Train Man tee shirts! Great design with a great feel to the material, as a matter of fact we love them so much we also went with the Sweatshirts as well!!! They’re great to keep you warm throughout the winter months and have Paradise on your mind! 🚂☮️💨🌴✌️😊

Women's Deck the Palms: All Is Calm V-Neck T-Shirts
Beth (Kansas City, KS, US)
Love my new Christmas shirt

The quality is top notch. I have bought several shirts over the last few years and they all still look like new, even after several washings.

Received my sign quick. I used it for door decoration on my Margaritville at Sea cruise. Great colors, very bright!

2 Pack Of Mystery Bag Zippered 12oz Neoprene Beer Coolers
Love our new beer cooler sleeves

The 2 mystery beer cooler sleeves that we received are so fitting for a couple that fishes! Also the one that my husband claimed matches the new tattoo he just got!
We were so surprised when we opened them!

Paul Brent Flip Flop Wristlet Bag Blue
Linda Larson (Seattle, WA, US)
Almost, not quite

Everything I've ordered so far has been exceptional. I'm a little disappointed with the catalog version vs the actual product for this one. I didn't see any color choice on the website? Will pass along to my granddaughter, I know she'll love it.

I'm The Cabana Boy T-Shirt
Carlon Chumley (Eden, NC, US)

Great shirt and even better Cabana boys!

We loved our shirts! So much fun for the ladies and the men played their part to perfection!!

I'm Not Waiting 'Til 5 O'clock Trademarked Hat
Margaret (Montgomery, NY, US)
Great fit!

This hat is a perfect fit especially if you have a big head.
The color is vibrant - I got the tangerine . It protects you from the sun and is comfortable and very cute and well made .

Cabana Boy Training Academy Heather T-Shirt
Beware...This is Cougar Bait!

Now, I purchased this t-shirt as a way to start my endeavor to help my local, aging females as they flock poolside this year. I am glad this shirt is well made, because once I put it on it was like a feeding frenzy... cougar style. I was serving up stiff drinks like a champ until all hell broke loose. Most of the over-50 moms were making snide remarks about testing out other, "stiff" things. I am not sure Cabana Boy training at Del Boca Vista was a good idea, but this shirt definitely was. One thing I learned during my tenure as Cabana Boy Apprentice was how to "Stop Short" and how to construct Fusilli sculptures of the aging beauties I served. Unfortunately, because of my prowress and burgeoning skill as a Cabana Boy, the Del Boca Vista HOA had to let me go. So, now I am back on the streets of Boca... but at least I have this great, well made and stylish shirt to keep me warm! Fins Up... Aloha & Mahalo!

You sir, are on your way to become a professional Cabana Boy. Your enthusiasm to make sure your patrons are satisfied is apparent and a key to the success of the cabana boy career path. May you look forward to a top level academic finish from our prestigious academy. - Island Jay

My girls and I love this shirt…in my husband…

He wears it with pride and lives up to the title!!!!!

Wood Bead & Howlite Sea Turtle Bracelet (2 Pack)
Timothy Collins (Kansas City, MO, US)
Love it!

Love the bracelets I ordered. Great fit and fast as always shipping. Excellent customer service.

Drinks Well With Others Flat Bottle Opener
Richard Frost (Lenoir, NC, US)
Love It!

I bought 2 of these festive bottle openers. I get so many people asking me when I got those! I highly recommend this product.

Women's Drinks Well With Others V-Neck
Maria Elena Sandoval (Ogden, UT, US)
Drinks well with others shirt

Hands down one of the best companies to order from. I ordered 2 sizes too big because I’m used to online clothes fitting small, so when I emailed them to return the product, I was told to go ahead and keep it and they would send me the correct size. Katie was friendly and professional with her response! Not only is customer service top notch, the quality of the products are above par as well. So now I get to give this shirt as a gift to someone else to enjoy! Thanks Island Jay! You have a customer for life!