Mystery Bag Hat
Mystery Bag Hat
Mystery Bag Hat

Mystery Bag Hat

$ 9.95 Regular price $ 24.95 Sale priceSave $ 15.00

We securely accept: Visa, Mastercard, Discover, American Express, PayPal, Apple Pay, & Google Pay.

Processing Time: Island Jay prints, packs, and ships your orders from Florida within a few business days.

Free or Ground Shipping:  Orders with free shipping or ground shipping will arrive about 5-10 days after your order is placed.

Get It Faster Shipping: Your order will be processed faster & will ship with Priority Mail. It will arrive 3-5 days after your order is placed. 

You can reach Island Jay in may ways

  • Call us Mon-Fri 10-4 EST 813-992-6550
  • Click Here to fill out our contact form

90 Day Returns: Island Jay offers a 90 day return policy for a refund or exchange.

Free Returns: If you need to make a return or exchange within the USA, we will send you a prepaid return label. 

When you order a Mystery Bag be a surprise! If you love Island Jay hats, this is a great chance to get a one of a kind or vintage design. 

If you like to live on the edge, then here is your chance. No scary mystery to solve here. 

We have a LOT of left over hats that are brand new....and we mean a LOT! These are left over styles, samples, or unique hats.. All 100% new & never used. Photos show an example of what you may get. 

We are going to blow them out at 60% OFF! Of course, 90-day returns and exchanges are welcome. Please keep in mind we cannot honor any special design requests.

Sorry, no back orders or rain checks. When these are gone, they are gone!


Island Jay's hats have all the features you need when hitting the beach this summer. Our unstructured, full fitting, low profile design ensures that you won't be squinting in the sun while trying to find your spot in the sand.

The mesh lining is stitched with Cool Crown technology that helps keep you cooler so you can stay comfortable as you sip away at the beach bar. And not to mention our hats come complete with a back adjustable strap & locking brass closure so it fits perfectly - no more worrying about losing it in the wind!


Island Jay: Your One-Stop Destination for Relaxation

Island Jay: Your One-Stop Destination for Relaxation

As the Chief Relaxation Officer, my goal is to help you embrace the beach lifestyle and find peace and tranquility in your everyday life.

Our collection of beach products is carefully curated to help you bring the essence of paradise into your home. But at Island Jay, we believe in more than just shopping. That's why we encourage you to explore our blog posts and social media pages, where you'll find inspiration and advice on how to live the beach life.

So why wait? Take a 60-second break from reality and come back to Island Jay. Whether you're shopping for beach products or just looking for a moment of peace and relaxation, you'll find what you need to "Relax Your Life" here.

Yours in tropical relaxation,
Island Jay

Customer Reviews

Based on 9 reviews
Katmac (Wisconsin Rapids, WI, US)

I ordered a shirt for my husband, I thought what the heck… order the surprise hat deal. He got the shirt, I received a cute hat and it totally fits my personality! It was a win win!

Diana Roe Hollis (Stone Mountain, GA, US)
Mystery hat

My husband likes it

Erin Nelson (Angier, NC, US)
Trucker Hat

The hat is really good quality, unfortunately I don't wear red and they sent me a red hat that is a bit too masculine for my liking.

Vicki Beaugh (Gulf Breeze, FL, US)
mystery hat

loved it!

James Otis (Sun City Center, FL, US)
Great stuff

Love the shirts and hat it’s nice not knowing what your are getting

Rosemarie. Mucci (Meriden, CT, US)

Would have loved if the hat was more generic !! I don’t live in Florida but love the quality of your products

Patricia G. (Daytona Beach, FL, US)
Great cap

Nice great cap

Mark McDowell (Albuquerque, NM, US)
Great hat

Wish it would have come with a bottle of rum, heavy sigh, but understandable 😀

Cheryl Mudrich (Lorain, OH, US)
Love this

I ordered the hats not knowing which one's I would get. I received 2 womens hats. I love them both but wish I would of gotten 1 of womens and 1 of mens.

Recently viewed