Island Jay's Caribbean Rum Punch Recipe

Caribbean Rum Punch Recipe

Island Jay's Caribbean Rum Punch is a captivating and refreshing rum-based drink that I have had the pleasure of sampling on my visits to the various different tropical destinations. Every tropical destination seems to have a unique twist to how they make their rum punch, which varies depending on the type of rum used and the juices blended into it.

The taste of a cold glass of rum punch adorned with pieces of fresh fruit will fly your mind away to the Caribbean islands and leave you basking in the sweet rays of the tropical sun. Even if you are not in a lower latitude, there is no reason why you cannot envision sitting by a beautiful white sandy beach sipping your rump punch.

Here are the ingredients for Island Jay's Caribbean Rum Punch Recipe. The next time you want to feel as if you are on a tropical vacation, follow these instructions;

Here is Island Jay's Rum Punch Recipe


  • 1 ounce of Silver Rum
  • 1 ounce of Coconut Rum
  • 1 ounce of Mango Rum

Other Stuff

  • 1.5 ounces of orange juice
  • 1.5 ounces of cranberry juice
  • 1.5 ounces of pineapple juice
  • Splash of grenadine
  • Ice cubes
  • Pineapple slice for garnish

How to prepare the rum punch

  1. Fill up your glass with ice
  2. Next, pour in the three rums into your glass.
  3. Then add in the three juices
  4. Shake to mix well or blend in a blender
  5. Garnish with pineapple slices
  6. Then serve and share with your friends. Trust me, they will all be asking you for tips on how to make such a refreshing Caribbean rum punch.


Previous Post Next Post

Comments 13
  • Gale Wood
    Gale Wood

    Thanks For Sharing!! Going to make this at Panama City !!

  • Debbie Forehand
    Debbie Forehand

    I’m going to try making this drink. I love these kind of drinks

  • Debbie Forehand
    Debbie Forehand

    I’m going to try making this drink. I love these kind of drinks

  • Jason Guarino
    Jason Guarino

    Just caught that typo. Thanks!

  • Lynn

    Now it says “3 2 rums” Is that supposed to be 32? Is “someone” taste testing the recipe as they type? ?

  • Sonya

    Can a different rum replace the coconut rum and still have the same flavor?

  • Island Jay
    Island Jay

    Sorry about that error in the recipe. It has been corrected. Steve, there is no reason why you cannot add an extra shot to anything!

  • Cindy

    I can’t print any of them. There is no recipe, only name of the drink. Please include recipes for these fantastic Rum drinks.

  • Shelly

    Print these for me

  • Patti

    I was wondering the same thing Steve was.

  • Gwen

    Heading to Key West for vacation and going to match up Jay’s Rum Punch to the Rum Runners they serve at Sunset Pier. Now those come with a test tube shooter and are very powerful. We will send photos….. :)

  • Gina

    I made this for girls night. We absolutely loved it and had one hell of a good time.
    Thank you for sharing

  • Steve Contos
    Steve Contos

    Our ingredients say 3 rums at 1 ounce reach, then in the Prep section you say to put “your 2 rums” in…and no mention of the 3rd..what’s up wit dat? Where does the 3rd one go?
    Do I do a chilled shot?
    Which one is left out of your “Rum Punch”?
    Which is for my chilled shooter?

Leave a comment
Your Name:*
Email Address:*
Message: *
* Required Fields