Island Jay Product Reviews

Island Jay Product & Store Reviews


I am pleased that you took the time to explore Island Jay. Congrats on beginning your journey toward relaxation.

Thousands of travelers have documented their happy experiences here on the Island. If you are unsure about joining the Island Jay family, I would encourage you to sit back, make a cocktail, and explore their words of wisdom.

- Island Jay.

Based on 27707 reviews
So Many Great Looks

Wore our new T-shirts for St. Paddy’s day and to a wine festival. The looks we received were hilarious. Great quality t-shirt. Fit just right!

Women's Drink Me I'm Magically Delicious V-Neck T-Shirt
Shirley Hudson (Oklahoma City, OK, US)
Great shirts

Perfect shirts. I like them. Got them a little looser because I'm in a rehab hospital and just lounging around.

Women's Fiesta Mamacita Needs a Margarita V-Neck T-Shirt
Lorrie Turner (Pickerington, OH, US)
Fiesta Mamacita

I LOVE THIS SHIRT!!! Perfect Fit too!!

Tiki Man Radio Hoodie

Excellent service, excellent material, love all my Island Jay shirts, hats, cups and stickers. This purple hoodie is great and I love wearing it, get all kinds of compliments every time I wear it. . . "Cheers Y'all!"

Felicia !!

I love my new long sleeve T-shirt ! I get so many compliments !

"Happy Beach Bum"

The Beach Is My Happy Place CUSTOMIZE 12oz Wine Tumblers, we purchased from Island Jay, are perfect for our pool & patio! We are looking forward to taking them to "Our Happy Beach!" They keep our Reggae Wines Cold longer and we will order more for some great gifts to our other "Beach Loving Friends!" Cheers Y'all! <3 <3 <3

Too small

I really loved the look of this shirt but it runs extremely small. Wish I had read the reviews first, I would not have ordered. I am 40” in the chest, 2X should have worked. Nope, way too snug. I ordered 2X in another tee and it was just fine.

Hi Connie, Anna here to help and sorry you are not happy with your purchase. Our goal is your 100% satisfaction and we would like to offer you a replacement with no need to return anything back to us. Please reply back to our email so we can get you taken care of. Thank you, Anna.

Shamrocks and Shenanigans Soft Style Pullover Hoodie
Patricia Kirwan (San Francisco, CA, US)
Great sweatshirt!!!

Fits perfect!
Extremely comfortable

Women's Where Is My Cabana Boy Long Sleeve T-Shirt * CLOSEOUT *
R & A Hyde (Albany, NY, US)
I found my Cabana Boy

Superior quality! Great Fit! We were excited to wear these shirts.

Winter Sucks Island Soft Style Pullover Hoodie
Becky Blair (Jonesville, MI, US)
Great Hoodie!!

Love the color and feel of the hoodie! Very comfortable. Bright and vivid colors in it. I live in Michigan so the winter sucks is how I feel about it.

Winter Sucks Island Metal Tumbler
Brian Janucik (Cape Coral, FL, US)

Was sent to a friend in cold, snowy Nebraska. She Loved it

Parrot Heads For The Palm Beaches Metal Tumbler
Hotrod (West Palm Beach, FL, US)
Ahhhhh…ParrotHeads of the Palm Beach Tumbler

Ahh….grab a chair, watch a fine Florida sunset with some rum (Papas Pilar) and coke in a great tumbler. Great detail and nicely made.

Retired But Not Expired Sweatshirt
Chris Geer (Mesa, AZ, US)
Perfect for anyone Retiring

Every product from Island Jay I ‘ve purchased is great quality and the service is Outstanding. I have had comments on Everything sweatshirt and Long Sleeve and Short Sleeve T-Shirt I’ve worn and especially this one “Retied But Not Expired. I know this has my friends and others looking to Island Jay for unique phrases on quality merchandise.

Florida Strong Englewood Flag T-Shirt
Mark Nelson (Englewood, FL, US)
Amazing shirt quality

This shirt is so cool and got lots of compliments when wearing it about staying strong after hurricane Ian departed and we survived and rebuilding

Women's Deck The Palms V-Neck T-Shirts
Peggy Bertsch (Daytona Beach, FL, US)
Runs Big

The description said Fitted and it runs huge. I usually wear a large but orders XL since it was Fitted. Could be a nice night shirt.

I just luv my Florida Strong T!

I just love my Florida, strong T-shirt… It’s such a vibrant, turquoise, color, quality cotton, and a beautiful, meaningful design! And I love that part of the purchase goes to the hurricane Ian victims. I bought a T-shirt for my brother and a couple of my girlfriends, and they all love it! I don’t have a photo of my V-neck tee, but here’s one of my tank top, which I love equally as well!

Vinyl is good quality

Vinyl is good quality, only wore and washed one time and stitching is coming out on the tank top.

Hi Mary, Anna here to help. Quality control is a huge part of what we do…so is stellar customer service. Once in a while a “bad egg” slips through during manufacturing…and we always do our best to make things right! We will send you another shirt after a few business days. Please keep us posted. Thanks! Anna

Florida Strong FLORIDA LOVE Long Sleeve T-Shirt
Diana Concannon (Nashville, TN, US)
Color fade

I received my shirt and I washed it in cold water inside out and it doesn’t hold the bright beautiful color that I saw once I received it in the mail

Hi Diana, Anna here to help. Quality control is a huge part of what we do…so is stellar customer service. Once in a while a “bad egg” slips through during manufacturing…and we always do our best to make things right! We will send you another shirt after a few business days. Please keep us posted. Thanks! Anna

Good quality and fit

The shirt is a nice quality and fit. Not overly baggy or too snug. The color is very pretty too.

Women's Florida Strong FLORIDA LOVE Long Sleeve T-Shirt
Gail Zmyslowski (Fort Myers, FL, US)
I usually love your shirts but…..

I was disappointed that the seam was improperly sewn so I have not worn it. The idea to help hurricane victims with relief funds is fabulous!!

Florida Strong woman’s shirt

I love my shirt! It fit well, washed well and kept its shape and color! My husband loves his as well! The pink one I got also fits nicely and have had a lot of Compliments on all of them! I love the Florida strong Florida love Florida life design! The primary colors look great!

Starfish & Turtle Seedbead Anklet
Patty Large (Cape Coral, FL, US)
Starfish & Turtles

Love this anklet! Slips on and fits perfect. The detailing is beautiful!

Florida Strong FLORIDA LOVE T-Shirt * Closeout *
Anonymous (East Dubuque, IL, US)

So happy to support my favorite vacation area! This tee is now my favorite night shirt...I ordered it big! The quality is spot on and the shipping updates VERY entertaining! 🤣😒

Florida Strong T

I love the shirt, the material is so comfortable. I would suggest to order a size up than you normally wear if you like them a little loose fitting like I do. I wear it proudly to support everyone affected by Hurrican Ian. I'll be shopping for more items since so many new things have been added. Thank you for your donations and commitment to help the residents of Florida.

Great shirts! Awesome customer service!

We bought shirts for us and our friends for our anniversary trip to Cancun. We needed different sizes for 2 of the shirts and customer service went above and beyond. They were great to work with and respond to emails...even on weekends! The quality of the shirts is great, we love our shirts and highly recommend Island Jay! Looking forward to wearing our shirts on our next vacation!